First impressions matter more than ever in the red-hot Long Island real estate market. With a historic low of only 3,200 homes for sale at the end of 2024—the lowest inventory since 2003, according to an Elliman Real Estate report featured on NBC NY—homebuyers are facing stiff competition. The median home price has surged to $700,000, and sellers need every advantage they can get to stand out.
One of the most powerful tools in a seller’s arsenal? Curb appeal. Whether you’re nestled in a coastal village or in one of the island’s bustling suburbs, your home’s exterior can be the make-or-break moment for buyers. Let’s dive into the top curb appeal trends turning heads and sealing deals in Long Island for 2025.
1. Natural, Flowing Landscaping
Say goodbye to rigid hedges and hello to romantic, organic gardens. HGTV’s 2025 trend report highlights a shift toward natural, flowing landscapes that blend effortlessly with Long Island’s lush surroundings. Native plants that evolve naturally help homes look established and timeless, which is especially important for newer builds trying to blend into Long Island’s historic neighborhoods.
2. Low-Water, Eco-Friendly Lawns
With sustainability at the forefront of their minds, homeowners are swapping out thirsty turf for low-maintenance alternatives. Think no-mow grasses, clover lawns, or flowering groundcovers—ideal for Long Island’s changing climate and eco-conscious buyers. Plus, they cut down on water bills, which is a bonus.
3. Bold Front Doors and Luxe Entryways
HGTV also notes that bold, saturated front doors and metal, modern finishes will dominate in 2025. A colorful front door in shades like deep teal or terra cotta is an easy and affordable way to grab attention, while a high-end entryway door makes a lasting impression. Don’t forget to upgrade the garage door ,too—wood or wood-look finishes can completely elevate your facade.
4. Bronze Over Black for Fixtures
Move over matte black—bronze is taking over for lighting fixtures, hardware, and even window accents. Warmer tones bring depth and elegance, complementing the earthy color palettes that are becoming more common in Long Island’s architectural updates.
5. Outdoor Living Is a Must-Have
With post-pandemic life still prioritizing open-air gatherings, outdoor dining spaces have become essential. From pea gravel patios with a fire pit to full-blown covered porches, even small outdoor zones add big appeal. Long Island’s coastal backdrop makes this trend even more impactful—imagine evening dinners with a salty breeze in your backyard.
6. Natural Roofing Materials for Charm and Durability
If you’re investing in a major exterior upgrade, consider a roof made from cedar, slate, or terra cotta tiles. Not only do these materials hold up well against Long Island weather, but they also add timeless beauty that buyers appreciate.
7. Water Features That Wow
A small koi pond, elegant fountain, or babbling waterfall can add serenity and luxury to your front yard. These features increase perceived value and offer a tranquil vibe that fits Long Island’s “coastal retreat” image, as Visit the USA describes.
Local Vibes That Boost Value
Living on Long Island isn’t just about square footage—it’s about lifestyle. Homebuyers are drawn to the region for its charming seaside villages, wine country, historic mansions, and vibrant cultural life. Whether you’re in Stony Brook or Sag Harbor, embracing this local flavor through landscaping, architecture, and exterior design can go a long way.
Include elements like nautical-inspired details, farmhouse lighting, or even a small vineyard-inspired trellis to reflect the area’s identity. Remember, selling here means selling more than just a home—you’re offering a piece of the Long Island dream.
Bonus Tip: Buy Before You Sell for a Smoother Transition
With houses selling fast and inventory tight, timing the sale of your current home with the purchase of a new one can be tricky. According to HomeLight, options like bridge loans—or their Buy Before You Sell program—can help homeowners tap into their home’s equity to fund a new purchase without needing to sell first. It’s a great way to avoid stress, strengthen your offer, and keep your move seamless.
Final Thoughts
Long Island homes are flying off the market, but those with killer curb appeal are fetching top dollar and selling the fastest. In 2025, buyers want character, sustainability, and a connection to the area’s unique charm. Whether you’re updating your front door, reimagining your landscaping, or creating an inviting outdoor space, small changes can lead to big returns.
And if you’re in a rush or overwhelmed by the prep? We Buy Houses Long Island services offer an alternative for sellers looking to move quickly—no staging or upgrades required.
But for those ready to shine, leaning into Long Island’s coastal-meets-classic aesthetic could be your ticket to a fast, profitable sale.