When I was selecting a new toilet for my bathroom, I quickly realized how important it was to choose the right shape, elongated or round. The decision isn’t just about looks; it also impacts comfort, space, and functionality.
Elongated toilets feature larger, oval-shaped bowls, providing a more spacious seating area for added comfort.
Round toilets, on the other hand, are more compact, making them a better fit for smaller bathrooms or spaces where saving room is essential.
When deciding between an elongated and a round toilet, it’s important to consider various factors, including the size of your bathroom, how much space you have available, and what type of seating comfort you’re looking for.
In this guide, I’ll break down the differences between elongated and round toilets to help you choose the best option for your space.
What Is an Elongated Toilet?
An elongated toilet has an oval-shaped bowl measuring about 18.5 inches, offering more seating space compared to the 16.5-inch round toilet.
This design offers increased comfort, making it a popular choice for many homeowners.
The extended length of the bowl allows for a more natural and relaxed seating posture, which is particularly beneficial for adults and individuals with mobility issues.
The added space also makes it easier to sit and stand, reducing strain during use. Elongated toilets are ideal for bathrooms with enough space, as they provide a more luxurious experience.
While they may require more room than round toilets, the comfort and ease of use they offer make them a preferred choice for those seeking long-term functionality and comfort.
Pros and Cons of Elongated Toilets
Elongated toilets offer enhanced comfort and modern design, but they require more space and come with a higher cost compared to round toilets.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Enhanced Comfort: The larger seating area provides more comfort for adults and individuals with mobility issues. | Space Requirements: They require more space, which might not be suitable for smaller bathrooms. |
| Modern Design: Elongated toilets often have a sleek, contemporary look that can complement modern bathroom style. | Higher Cost: Typically more expensive than round toilets, both in terms of purchase price and installation. |
| Easier Cleaning: The design can make cleaning more straightforward due to fewer hard-to-reach areas. | Not Ideal for Children: The larger size may be less suitable for young children, who might find it challenging to use comfortably. |
What Are Round Toilets?
Round toilets feature a traditional, circular bowl design, typically measuring around 16.5 inches from the mounting bolts to the front of the bowl.
This compact design makes round toilets an ideal choice for smaller bathrooms, as they take up less space compared to elongated models.
Round toilets are known for their affordability, as they generally have a lower upfront cost and installation expense. They are a practical option for homeowners working with limited bathroom space or those on a budget.
While round toilets are typically less comfortable for adults due to the smaller seating area, they can be more suitable for children.
Though they lack the comfort and sleek design of elongated toilets, round toilets remain a popular option due to their practicality and cost-effectiveness.
Pros and Cons of Round Toilets
Round toilets are space-efficient and cost-effective, but they may lack comfort and modern appeal compared to elongated models.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Space-Efficient: Their compact size makes them ideal for smaller bathrooms or powder rooms. | Less Comfortable: The smaller seating area may be less comfortable for adults or individuals with mobility issues. |
| Cost-Effective: Generally less expensive than elongated toilets, making them a budget-friendly option. | Traditional Appearance: Their classic design might not suit modern bathroom aesthetics. |
| Suitable for Children: The smaller size is often more appropriate for young children learning to use the toilet. | Harder to Clean: The smaller size can have more crevices, potentially making cleaning more challenging. |
Key Differences Between Elongated and Round Toilets
Understanding the distinctions between elongated and round toilets can assist in determining which is more suitable for your bathroom.
1. Size and Space Considerations
Elongated toilets require more space due to their larger, oval-shaped bowl. They are ideal for larger bathrooms where comfort and style are important.
However, their size may not be suitable for smaller spaces. In contrast, round toilets have a compact, circular bowl, making them perfect for smaller bathrooms or powder rooms where space is limited.
Their size allows them to fit comfortably into tight spaces.
2. Comfort and Usability
Elongated toilets are designed for comfort, offering more seating space, which makes them more comfortable for adults and individuals with mobility challenges.
The extended bowl helps provide a more natural seating posture, ideal for extended use. Round toilets, on the other hand, have a smaller seating area, which can be less comfortable for adults.
However, their size can be more suited for young children learning to use the toilet.
3. Visual Appeal
Elongated toilets typically feature a sleek, modern design that enhances the look of contemporary bathrooms. Their larger size and oval bowl create a more upscale look, which works well in bathrooms with ample space.
Round toilets, however, tend to have a more traditional appearance and are often chosen for classic or vintage-style bathrooms. Their design may not be as trendy, but it suits a more traditional or rustic decor.
4. Cleaning and Maintenance
Elongated toilets generally have fewer crevices, making them easier to clean. The extended bowl size allows for smoother surfaces, reducing areas where dirt and grime can accumulate.
Round toilets, being smaller in size, may have tighter spaces that can trap dirt, making cleaning a bit more challenging.
Both types need regular maintenance, but elongated toilets are easier to clean due to their design.
5. Cost and Availability
Elongated toilets are generally more expensive due to their larger size and more intricate design. They may also be less readily available in certain styles, making them less affordable for homeowners on a budget.
On the other hand, round toilets are more affordable, widely available, and ideal for homeowners seeking a cost-effective, functional option.
Should You Choose an Elongated or Round Toilet?
When deciding between an elongated or round toilet for your family, comfort and space should be top priorities.
Elongated toilets provide a larger, more comfortable seating area, making them ideal for adults and individuals with mobility challenges.
They offer greater comfort for longer use but may require more space in your bathroom. On the other hand, round toilets are smaller, more compact, and can be a better fit for smaller bathrooms.
Their size is also more appropriate for young children who are still learning to use the toilet.
While round toilets are typically more affordable and space-efficient, elongated toilets are a better choice for families where adults primarily use the bathroom.
But remember that the choice depends on your bathroom size, your family’s comfort preferences, and your budget. So, select the option that best suits your home and lifestyle.
Is an Elongated Toilet Worth the Extra Cost?
While elongated toilets tend to be more expensive than round toilets, many homeowners find the added cost worthwhile due to the enhanced comfort and modern design.
The larger, oval-shaped bowl offers more seating space, making it a more comfortable option for adults, individuals with mobility issues, and those who use the toilet for longer periods.
Additionally, elongated toilets are often associated with a sleeker, more contemporary bathroom aesthetic, which can enhance the overall look of your space.
The durability of these toilets also adds to their value, as they tend to last longer with proper maintenance.
However, if you’re working with a tight budget or have limited bathroom space, a round toilet might be a more practical choice.
Choosing the Right Toilet for Your Bathroom
Selecting the right toilet depends on factors like bathroom size, user comfort, and design preferences to ensure the best fit for your space and needs.
- Larger Bathrooms: An elongated toilet is ideal, offering enhanced comfort and a sleek, modern look.
- Smaller Bathrooms: A round toilet can save space while still providing the necessary functionality.
- Families with Children: Round toilets are more suitable for young children, while elongated toilets provide better comfort for adults.
- Individuals with Mobility Issues: Elongated toilets are more comfortable and easier to use, offering greater accessibility and convenience.
Conclusion
After considering the differences between elongated and round toilets, I’ve realized that each has its own benefits depending on factors like bathroom size, comfort, and style.
Elongated toilets offer more comfort and a modern design, making them ideal for larger bathrooms or adults, while round toilets are space-efficient and budget-friendly, perfect for smaller bathrooms or families with young children.
If you’re unsure which option is right for your home, I suggest consulting with a bathroom design expert to explore all the available choices.
They can guide you in finding the perfect toilet that meets your needs and enhances your bathroom experience. Ready to upgrade your bathroom? Contact a design professional today.